MMTC - Fundamental Analysis: Financial Health & Valuation

Last Updated Time : 19 Sept 25, 2:16 pm

Fundamental Rating: 2.9

📊 Core Financials Breakdown

Profit Volatility: PAT dropped 43.7% QoQ despite a spike from ₹0.27 Cr to ₹36.7 Cr — suggests inconsistency in earnings.

Return Metrics

ROCE: 8.33% — below average, indicating modest capital efficiency.

ROE: 5.69% — low shareholder return.

Debt Profile: Debt-to-equity of 0.00 — debt-free, which is a positive.

Cash Flow: Not disclosed, but low ROE and inconsistent PAT hint at weak operating cash generation.

💹 Valuation Indicators

Metric Value Commentary

P/E Ratio 209 Extremely high — implies overvaluation or distorted earnings base.

P/B Ratio ~6.83 High for a PSU with modest returns — not justified by fundamentals.

PEG Ratio 7.20 Very unattractive — suggests poor value relative to growth.

EPS ₹0.50 Weak earnings base.

🧠 Business Model & Competitive Advantage

MMTC is a government-owned trading entity specializing in

Commodities Trading: Metals, minerals, precious metals, coal, agro-products

1

.

Revenue Model: Acts as an intermediary — buys from producers/suppliers and sells to end-users at a margin

1

.

Diversification: Engages in third-country trading and joint ventures like Neelachal Ispat Nigam Ltd

1

.

Competitive Edge: Government backing and legacy relationships, but lacks pricing power and scalability compared to private peers

2

.

Despite its wide portfolio, MMTC suffers from low margins, high debtor days, and poor sales growth over the past five years

3

.

📈 Technical & Sentiment Indicators

RSI: 57.9 — neutral zone.

MACD: Slightly positive — mild bullish sentiment.

Volume: Below weekly average — suggests waning interest.

DMA 50/200: Price hovering around both — no clear trend.

🎯 Entry Zone & Long-Term Guidance

Suggested Entry Zone: ₹58–₹62 — closer to support levels and below moving averages.

Long-Term View: MMTC lacks strong fundamentals and consistent profitability. Unless there's a strategic turnaround or asset monetization, it’s best suited for speculative or short-term trades rather than long-term holding.

If you’re looking for stronger PSU plays, I can help you compare MMTC with NMDC or Hindustan Copper next.

1

www.thebusinessscroll.com

2

dcfmodeling.com

3

www.screener.in

Edit in a page